Nearby Places to Explore
Nearby Events
Services
Amenities
Payment Options
Parking Options
Location & Map
Find this place on Google Maps and get turn-by-turn directions before you go.
Google Reviews
AndrewAmazing ice cream and speedy service! Whether you are in the mood for soft serve (try it with a flavor burst or dipped in cherry or chocolate coating), floats (made with Saranac root beer!), or something unique (I've never had a Razzie anywhere else), you can't go wrong. Perfect treat after a round of mini golf next door at Nutty Putty and always a must visit during our annual trip to Old Forge!
Aug 3, 2026 · Google Review
Dominic MorrellHelped us get our car unlocked after our keys were locked inside, also great ice cream and mini golf course!
May 30, 2026 · Google Review
Sleeping BluetyBenny's has the creamiest soft serve in town. The toppings are outstanding. I really love the hot fudge and warm peanut butter on a vanilla sundae. When you support this business, you're contributing to the Old Forge community.
Aug 9, 2025 · Google Review
Andrew KolarWonderful reasonably priced ice cream! The owner and the girl working there were super nice too.
Jun 21, 2021 · Google Review
Samantha StamSpent the weekend in Old Forge with a bunch of family and decided to go grab ice cream on our last night. Benny's was our first choice because of the reviews, and they did not disappoint. Delicious, great portions, and not too expensive. The one girl working was friendly and efficient, with no complaints. She had a long line and made it go quick. Ice cream was delicious, not to mention the place is so darn cute!
Jul 27, 2023 · Google Review